It's all about
the Chili

We’ve been serving some of the nation’s best chili and hot dogs in New Castle, PA since 1923. Come visit us at the restaurant or order our famous chili sauce online and have it delivered to your door!



What Our Fans Are Saying

Modernly nostalgic, clean, spacious, plenty of seating and parking, friendly staff, paid $35 for 3 people. Food tasted good, filling. We wish they would steam their hotdog buns that would made them perfect. They have a pretty simple menu: burgers, hotdogs, fries, and fish sandwiches. It’s not an extensive menu, they keep it simple. And every-time I’ve gone in there for lunch, it’s been packed. Good time to go is 11 am right before the rush. It would nice if their big sign outside up front would light up and mention there’s a drive-thru (I didn’t realize there was drive-thru).
read more
media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1media thumbnail 2media thumbnail 3media thumbnail 4media thumbnail 5media thumbnail 6media thumbnail 7
Aunt Nessie Avatar
Aunt Nessie
My wife was born in New Castle so we come up from NC to New Castle to visit. Coney Island has great dogs and fries smothered in chili. Don’t expect a fancy expensive restaurant but expect an amazing and awesome taste of pure good old Americana.
read more
media thumbnail 0
Carlos Hernandez Avatar
Carlos Hernandez
Everything was delicious and prices were good. The chili is definitely worth trying even if your not normally a fan.
read more
media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1media thumbnail 2media thumbnail 3
RyanOC Avatar

Shop Online

Purchase From Anywhere

Online Store


Get in on the Action




Our famous chili sauce is available in several stores in western Pennsylvania, Ohio and even Buffalo, New York. Click the button below to find a location near you!

Chili Locator

About Us


M+P Coney Island was started in New Castle in 1923 by 2 Greek immigrants: John Mitsos and George Papazekos, hence the "M+P".

Learn More
John Mitsos and George Papazekos

Contact Us

Let’s Get In Touch

If you have questions about M+P Coney Island or this site, please reach out via this contact form or email us at