Reviews

Coney island is a classic. There's like 7 things on the menu and you can't go wrong. Hot dogs, burgers, fries, chili, cheese everything. Can't get chilli like this anywhere else!

I remember enjoying Coney Island way back in my youth. The aesthetic is timeless, from the tables to the baskets to the card readers. Honestly, it makes me feel proud to be an American.

If you like thin crispy golden hot fries, treat yourself to Coney Island. They consistency produce this feeling you're having right now. That's why no picture is needed. Also… I ate them too quickly. My order: double chili cheese burger,... read moreIf you like thin crispy golden hot fries, treat yourself to Coney Island. They consistency produce this feeling you're having right now. That's why no picture is needed. Also… I ate them too quickly. My order: double chili cheese burger, one with everything and a regular fry. Mixing in a milkshake is always a good choice too. read less

I'll start with this - I love a good hot dog. They're increasingly hard to find, so I was beyond excited to stumble upon MP Coney Island. Any restaurant that has been around for close to 100 years is doing... read moreI'll start with this - I love a good hot dog. They're increasingly hard to find, so I was beyond excited to stumble upon MP Coney Island. Any restaurant that has been around for close to 100 years is doing something right.They seem to get it all right! Basic no frills dining room that reminds you of a 80's burger joint. They staff was very friendly and informative, as I'd never visited before. I ordered 2 Chicago Dogs and a side of regular fries. The fries were golden and crispy outside, soft inside. The hot dogs were packed with toppings and tasted better than I'd imagined. The hot dogs are in the $2 range, which is incredible with today's pricing! I highly recommend. read less

A local gem indeed! I was a little skeptical at first but my husband is from the area and insisted we go here because they have the best cheeseburgers. I have to agree..this place is awesome. Everything is made fresh... read moreA local gem indeed! I was a little skeptical at first but my husband is from the area and insisted we go here because they have the best cheeseburgers. I have to agree..this place is awesome. Everything is made fresh and the small fries are enough to share. There is a reason this place has been open since 1923. read less

This place is a must if your in the New Castle area. Now it’s not the fanciest place but if you like chili dogs you have to give it a try.

If my pictures don’t convince you to stop then you don’t deserve too eat here... simply delicious will definitely add this to my list of favorites... everyone was very nice and friendly... thanks to all

great chilli sauce fries hamburger hot dogs milkshakes are great good food good service at a good price

Lawrence County is hot dog paradise, I can't take it when I'm on the road and can't find a good chili dog, but no chance of that with Coney Island nearby. The hard part is passing on the chili cheese... read moreLawrence County is hot dog paradise, I can't take it when I'm on the road and can't find a good chili dog, but no chance of that with Coney Island nearby. The hard part is passing on the chili cheese fries because I want to fill up on the hot dogs. Lots of other tasty stuff for you weirdos who have hot dog phobia. read less

I moved away from my hometown of New Castle..40 years ago but when ever I'm in town I HAVE TO HAVE THEIR hot dogs or chili and cheese hamburger. Then on my way out back home 600 miles away...I take... read moreI moved away from my hometown of New Castle..40 years ago but when ever I'm in town I HAVE TO HAVE THEIR hot dogs or chili and cheese hamburger. Then on my way out back home 600 miles away...I take the Chili back home. read less

Always fast service and consistently great food. I have been there several times and have never been disappointed.

Honestly i love their food. Their french fries are amazing and so are the hamburgers. I have eaten here several times in the past and have not been disappointed yet.

I've been eating Coney Island hot dogs since I was in college. The dogs are great. Get one (or three) with "everything" is the only way to go.