Reviews

Modernly nostalgic, clean, spacious, plenty of seating and parking, friendly staff, paid $35 for 3 people. Food tasted good, filling. We wish they would steam their hotdog buns that would made them perfect. They have a pretty simple menu: burgers, hotdogs, fries, and fish sandwiches. It’s not an extensive menu, they keep it simple. And every-time I’ve gone in there for lunch, it’s been packed. Good time to go is 11 am right before the rush. It would nice if their big sign outside up front would light up and mention there’s a drive-thru (I didn’t realize there was drive-thru).

It’s not a bad spot, I prefer the buns to be a little toasted and the cheese is different than my usual spots but the chili is the real rockstar here. It’s very very good. The fact they sell it to go in various sizes will allow you to make your burgers and dogs to your preference and add their delicious chili later. Still pretty good all in all.

My wife was born in New Castle so we come up from NC to New Castle to visit. Coney Island has great dogs and fries smothered in chili. Don’t expect a fancy expensive restaurant but expect an amazing and awesome taste of pure good old Americana.

I have loved this place since I was a child! Has always been my favorite Hot Dog shop in a city that was once considered THE Hot Dog capital of America! The only reason for the 4 stars instead of 5 was that my dogs were barely warm while my fries were piping hot. Other than that, this will continue to be my one and only dog stop in town!

Everything was delicious and prices were good. The chili is definitely worth trying even if your not normally a fan.

If you're looking for a New Castle chili dog this isn't it. It's playing to it's own song not like anyone else's Chili. The first thing you see is it is not evern the same color. The hotdog its self is above average. Hey some people like it. There was customers coming and going all the time we were there. I must admit it is not my cup of tea. To each his own.

Best hotdog chilli sauce in the world. These hotdogs are just so simple and simply the absolute best! I live in Columbus Ohio but every time I make the 3 hour 200 mile trip to Newcastle Pennsylvania, I do NOT leave without going here one time at the very least! The fry portions are huge! And the dressed up hotdogs are so inexpensive in a world that everything is expensive and going up in price! The staff are sweet as well! Kid-friendliness: Has an awesome kid's menu and at an easy to find spot on the board alongside everything else. Parking: Plenty of free parking here. Wheelchair accessibility: No steps. Gradual concrete incline to the sidewalk from parking making it nice and easy to reach the doors.

It's been years since I came across a Coney Island and I have to say that this one by far is the most cleanest and comfortable environment to get a bite to eat. The staff is very welcoming and excited to serve you. And the manager Rosemary is it great and wonderful person I will definitely be coming back to this establishment just because of her and the rest of the staff thanks again for your service. Your friends from direct marketing group.

I grew up in this area and even worked at this establishment in the 90s. Their chili sauce was legendary. I now live in Kentucky and every time a family member comes to visit I ask them to bring me chili from Cony's. However the chili is not as good as it was in the 90s. The last time I was in town I noticed Cony Island was trying to franchise. Bowling Green KY. sure could use one of these here, just sayin, and bring Pizza Joe's with you.

Place was great! Employees are very friendly and truly engaged in the customer experience! Went as far to make sure I enjoyed my dinner. Great conversation about other types of foods from other areas. I truly enjoyed my experience here.

Coney island is a classic. There's like 7 things on the menu and you can't go wrong. Hot dogs, burgers, fries, chili, cheese everything. Can't get chilli like this anywhere else!

I remember enjoying Coney Island way back in my youth. The aesthetic is timeless, from the tables to the baskets to the card readers. Honestly, it makes me feel proud to be an American.

If you like thin crispy golden hot fries, treat yourself to Coney Island. They consistency produce this feeling you're having right now. That's why no picture is needed. Also… I ate them too quickly. My order: double chili cheese burger, one with everything and a regular fry. Mixing in a milkshake is always a good choice too.

I'll start with this - I love a good hot dog. They're increasingly hard to find, so I was beyond excited to stumble upon MP Coney Island. Any restaurant that has been around for close to 100 years is doing something right.They seem to get it all right! Basic no frills dining room that reminds you of a 80's burger joint. They staff was very friendly and informative, as I'd never visited before. I ordered 2 Chicago Dogs and a side of regular fries. The fries were golden and crispy outside, soft inside. The hot dogs were packed with toppings and tasted better than I'd imagined. The hot dogs are in the $2 range, which is incredible with today's pricing! I highly recommend.

A local gem indeed! I was a little skeptical at first but my husband is from the area and insisted we go here because they have the best cheeseburgers. I have to agree..this place is awesome. Everything is made fresh and the small fries are enough to share. There is a reason this place has been open since 1923.

This place is a must if your in the New Castle area. Now it’s not the fanciest place but if you like chili dogs you have to give it a try.

If my pictures don’t convince you to stop then you don’t deserve too eat here... simply delicious will definitely add this to my list of favorites... everyone was very nice and friendly... thanks to all

great chilli sauce fries hamburger hot dogs milkshakes are great good food good service at a good price

My husband loves the coney dogs with pickle of course, I thought the food was good, not best and the place could be a bit cleaner!

Lawrence County is hot dog paradise, I can't take it when I'm on the road and can't find a good chili dog, but no chance of that with Coney Island nearby. The hard part is passing on the chili cheese fries because I want to fill up on the hot dogs. Lots of other tasty stuff for you weirdos who have hot dog phobia.

I've been eating Coney Island hot dogs since I was in college. The dogs are great. Get one (or three) with "everything" is the only way to go.